Notion: The youth today are LESS PREPARED for their future than their parent's generation.
Proposition:
Hwa Chong InstitutionOpposition: United world college
Well i must confessed that the United world college deserved to win. I like the style in which they have presented their case; their charm were of the top class. Points wise, they have a clearer direction of what they are arguing for as compared to
Hwa Chong. Besides that, the United world college is more supreme and comfortable in their mastery of the language.
Now some opinion of mine on the notion itself:
Firstly, i must say that
Hwa Chong do have quite a few
good points in which they failed to put
together to support their stand on the notion. For example: Factors such as skill, knowledge and attitude that is deemed to be (COMMON) issues which both generations face. However, what they have failed to put up a good fight on these Great points is that they did not set a COMMON PLATFORM for the two generations to be compared effectively on. And those 3 factors mentioned above could very well be the common factors faced by both generations when trying to establish a common platform for them to compared. This is the key to link back to the notion that one party is LESS (this is the keyword we consider) Prepared than the other. Now the
Hwa Chong has touched on the point but failed to make an
explicit case on it. (which I find rather
unfortune) They
shld never make any assumption that the opposition or the audience understand what they are trying to imply between the lines. Being very
explicit is the way to kill
the opponent when they tried to smoke through, esp. you know that they are very persuasive and charming in giving audience impressions. (Don't give them the chance to do that!)
Secondly, on debating
tatics. We do get nervous and tongue tied sometimes but that
shld not occur too freq. Eye contact is one of the key
factors. For
Hwa Chong, I find speaker no. 2 has a better style than the other 2 debaters.
Overall, i see great potential lies ahead for all the debaters from both parties. I hope you all find my comments helpful. =)